Re: Ratty and Rat Rights
<< Previous Message | Next Message >>
From: | "J. A. Kiernan" <jkiernan@julian.uwo.ca> |
To: | Simon Smith <ssmith@skeletech.com> |
Reply-To: | |
Content-Type: | TEXT/PLAIN; charset=US-ASCII |
On Fri, 21 Apr 2000, Simon Smith wrote:
> mouse = murine [ Latin: mus = mouse or rat ] ...
> goat = caprine.....etc
> So what's a rat?
> Rattine would be a logical choice but isn't particularly satisfying, ...
A wonderful question, and what is the answer?
You're quite right that "rattine" is not on: partly because the
similar word "ratine" (also spelled "rateen") is of French origin,
meaning a type of loosely woven fabric for clothing. In this day
and age, we need more than doubling a "t" to make a new word.
The other -ine words are all from Latin roots, and so are others
such as "leporine" (hare) and "leonine" (lion). The English "rat"
comes from the Old English "rat," and was usurped into scientific
nomenclature in the 18th century as the generic name for rats
(Rattus norvegicus etc). The Spanish words for rat and mouse are
almost identical, evidently from rattus rather than the Latin mus.
The Latin for a rat is "mus." Unfortunately this word is also the
Latin for mouse, so "murine" should be classically correct for both
rodents. Scientists, unfortunately, picked on the mouse selectively
for the descriptive adjective. This is a blatant instance of sizism.
The ancient Romans discriminated against rats, humiliating them by
giving them with the name given to mice. The ignorant Romans must
have perceived mice as more lovable or less threatening on account
of their smaller sizes.
If all this came before the Supreme Court of Canada, the rats would
undoubtedly win the right to be designated as "murine" by whining
about discrimination on the grounds of sizism. The decision (even
if it were a 5:4 majority of this august clique of unelected
twerps) would become The Law, even if it overturned an act of
parliament passed by a large majority of the elected representatives
of the human population of the country. Canadian rats are therefore
murine in Canada. Let's accept it and avoid a lot of costly
litigation.
This does not solve the question in the rest of the world. Rats
still lack an etymologically consistent modern English adjective
that distinguishes them from smaller (or bigger) rodents.
Sorry not to end with an answer, but perhaps the above remarks
will prompt someone else to come up with a ratty adjective that
hits the spot for all.
John A. Kiernan,
Department of Anatomy & Cell Biology,
The University of Western Ontario,
LONDON, Canada N6A 5C1
<< Previous Message | Next Message >>